The Ghost of Christmas Yet to Come
: Why Our Pursuit of "Success" is a Blueprint for Misery
The chimes of Christmas bells, even in the dog days of summer, can conjure an image: Ebenezer Scrooge, that covetous, bitter miser from Dickens's "A Christmas Carol." His transformation, orchestrated by spectral visitations, is a literary cornerstone. Yet, beyond the charming parable lies a brutal, often overlooked truth—one that speaks directly to the hollow core of modern ambition. Shane Parrish, in his incisive analysis, "Clear Thinking," uses Scrooge not as a quaint fable, but as a dire warning: heed the lessons of past, present, and yet-to-come, or find yourself trapped in a self-made hell.
Scrooge, initially, is a poster child for what society, and our own base instincts, often value: untrammelled greed, relentless acquisition, and a climb up the greasy pole of power and status. His world is one of transactional relationships, where human connection is a liability, and empathy, a weakness. He embodies the "society's scoreboard" mentality, driven by a primal, biological urge for hierarchy. The narrative of his ghostly journey is not merely about redemption, but the stark revelation of the consequences of this relentless pursuit: isolation, contempt, and the chilling spectre of regret. His epiphany, when it arrives, is a gut-wrenching realisation that the wealth, the status, the supposed "victories" he accumulated, were empty things, utterly devoid of meaning without the warmth of genuine human connection. The man had won the game, only to find the prize was a handful of dust.
This isn't a phenomenon confined to Victorian London or the pages of English literature. The "hedonic treadmill," a concept introduced by Brickman and Campbell, elucidates this perpetual chase. Consider the initial rush of securing that first car, or the fleeting thrill of a promotion. That initial euphoria, as Parrish meticulously details, dissipates swiftly, replaced by a new baseline of expectation. We become "happy-when" people, perpetually deferring contentment to some future acquisition or achievement. The insidious nature of this cycle is magnified by comparison – a disease of our hyper-connected age. "Comparison is the thief of joy," as Theodore Roosevelt so aptly put it, and it fuels this treadmill, ensuring constant dissatisfaction as we measure our own meagre gains against the seemingly boundless successes of others. It’s a rigged game, tailored to ensure you always feel a step behind.
And for those who doubt the contemporary relevance of Scrooge's plight, Parrish offers a chilling modern parallel: the CEO. This titan of industry, a man who, like Scrooge, believed his "lion" mentality elevated him above the "opinions of a sheep," amassed a fortune and wielded considerable power. He chewed people up and spat them out, seeing only stepping stones where others saw colleagues. Upon retirement, however, the brutal truth dawned: the "friends" who had tolerated his abrasiveness, the colleagues who had endured his tyranny, simply vanished. Their connections, built on professional obligation and fear, not genuine rapport, dissolved into thin air. He was left with his wealth, his empty accolades, and the agonising realisation that he had spent his life "trying to win the wrong game." Unlike Scrooge, there was no benevolent spirit to offer a second chance, no spectral intervention to reverse the irreversible damage wrought by a life misspent. The game was over, and he’d lost everything that truly mattered.
This brings us to the missing ingredient, the phantom limb for so many of our "successful" individuals: phronesis. The ancient Greeks understood that "know-how" – the technical skill to achieve a goal – is distinct from "know-what" – the wisdom to discern which goals are truly worth pursuing. Many brilliant minds, equipped with sharp intellect and relentless drive, are masters of execution but utterly blind to the fundamental question of purpose. They can build empires, but they don't know what to build them for. Phronesis is the practical wisdom that allows one to order their life for optimal flourishing, moving beyond mere effectiveness to grasp what genuinely matters. It’s the ability to pause amidst the frantic chase and ask: What the hell am I actually doing this for?
The bluntness of these examples is not for shock value; it's a desperate plea for introspection. In a world obsessed with metrics, with scaling, with perpetually "optimising" every facet of our lives, we risk becoming high-functioning Scrooges, accumulating external trophies while our inner lives wither. The true ghost of Christmas yet to come isn't a spectral warning, but the quiet, creeping despair of a life lived for the wrong reasons. The time to ask "what's worth wanting" isn't at the end, when the game is up, but now, before the cold, hard reality of regret settles in. Don't wait for your own spirits to appear; the lesson is there, staring you in the face.
Citations:
Parrish, Shane. Clear Thinking. Portfolio, 2023. (This is the primary source referenced in the provided text).
Dickens, Charles. A Christmas Carol. 1843. (The literary work central to the discussion).
Brickman, Philip, and Donald T. Campbell. "Hedonic Relativism and Planning the Good Society." In Adaptation-Level Theory: A Symposium, edited by M.H. Apley. New York: Academic Press, 1971. (For the concept of the hedonic treadmill).
Roosevelt, Theodore. (Attributed quote: "Comparison is the thief of joy").
Ancient Greek philosophy (for the concept of phronesis).
Event Portfolio
Street Portfolio